Two stocks in Financial Services
American Express vs Progressive: profit, growth, debt and price compared
Progressive is stronger on 4 of 7 figures: debt, price for its expected profit, dividend and price trend. American Express is stronger on 3: profit margin, sales growth and analysts' view.
Save both stocks to your watchlist and revisit their latest fundamentals.
| American ExpressAXP | ProgressivePGR | |
|---|---|---|
| Net margin | Stronger: 27.9% | 12.7% |
| Revenue growth, past year | Stronger: +7.84% | +3.02% |
| Debt to equity | 167.6% | Stronger: 24.3% |
| Forward P/E | 15.6× | Stronger: 14.1× |
| Dividend yield | 1.16% | Stronger: 6.08% |
| Analysts | Stronger: Buy · 24 | Hold · 21 |
| From its 200-day average | −2.5% | Stronger: +5.6% |
Share price over the past year
- American Express−7.4%
- Progressive+1.6%
18 Nov 202518 Nov 2026
American Express or Progressive: which is stronger?
- AXP
Which is more profitable?
American Express keeps more of each sale as profit: 27.9% against 12.7%.
- AXP
Which is growing its sales faster?
American Express is growing its sales faster: +7.84% over the past year, against +3.02%.
- PGR
Which has borrowed less?
Progressive has borrowed less: its debt is 24.3% of what its shareholders own, against 167.6% for American Express.
- PGR
Which costs less for the profit it is expected to make?
Progressive costs less for the profit it is expected to make: 14.1× its forward earnings, against 15.6×.
- PGR
Which pays more in dividends?
Progressive pays more back in dividends for what a share costs: 6.08% a year, against 1.16%.
- AXP
Which do analysts rate higher?
Analysts are warmer on American Express: Buy, against Hold for Progressive.
- PGR
Which is in the stronger price trend?
Progressive's price is in the stronger trend: 5.6% above its 200-day average, against 2.5% below.
What each company does
AXPAmerican Express
American Express Company, together with its subsidiaries, operates as an integrated payments company in the United States, Europe, the Middle East and Africa, the Asia Pacific, Australia, New Zealand, Latin America, and internationally.
Reports results on 29 January 2027
PGRProgressive
The Progressive Corporation operates as an insurance company in the United States.
Reports results on 27 January 2027
This comparison is just the starting point.
Discover opportunities, understand companies and compare investments in one place. See how StratDeck works
Keep researching
Where next
More comparisons
Free email
Up to speed in minutes, four times a week
Every Monday, know what moved AI stocks and what to watch next. Every Wednesday and Friday, find a stock worth a look and learn its story. Every Sunday, catch up on the market's week in two minutes.
Early access
Become a StratDeck founding user
Use StratDeck, tell us what's missing, and help decide what we build next.
100 founding places. Founding users get their first month free, then half price for life: £2.99 a month or £30 a year.